Story Summary
Comments
WARNING! Comments may contain spoilers for a chapter or story. Read with caution.
From the Ashes
telpethoniel - 21 Feb 06 - 2:18 AM
This is very poetic, and I'm a published poet (hard cover book form) this is very well written
Keep up the good work
From the Ashes
Werecat - 05 Mar 06 - 6:06 AM
Hi there!
Better late than never, I guess. I just wanted to let you know how much I enjoyed reading your story when it passed review. It was about time someone gave original characters a chance. :)
Thank you for sharing this with us,
Werecat
From the Ashes
EdorasLass - 07 Mar 06 - 6:11 PM
Telpethoniel - Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it. :)
EL
From the Ashes
EdorasLass - 07 Mar 06 - 6:12 PM
Werecat - anytime's a good time for feedback :) . I keep trying to think of something else to do with these two characters, because I like them myself, but so far, no nuzgul. Glad you liked it!
EL
From the Ashes
DKP - 23 Oct 06 - 5:10 PM
I was in the mood for a romance when I saw this in the Featured Story section, and what a reward! I fell in love with Mereneth and Renward. You fleshed out these OCs beautifully and gave them such a sweet courtship. It was nice to see, as Eomer said, "...that happiness has come of this war." The ending was very sweet, and I also thought you handled their first night together particularly well. I hope you find more stories for them - surely there's something to be written about a "regular" Gondorian making a new life in Rohan?
Denise
From the Ashes
RiverOtter - 24 Oct 06 - 7:59 AM
From the Ashes
EdorasLass - 24 Oct 06 - 9:14 PM
DKP -
I'm glad to hear that you liked Renward and Mereneth - I was a bit hesitant to post something that had almost no canon characters in it!
I haven't really written anything post-War, but if I do, I'll make an effort to include these two OCs, because I really like them, too.
Thanks!
From the Ashes
EdorasLass - 24 Oct 06 - 9:16 PM
Hiya, Riverotter!
I'm still never quite sure where this story came from - it's so different in tone than the type of thing I usually write. Glad to hear you liked it, and thank you so much!
EL
Comments are hidden to prevent spoilers.
Click header to view comments
