Comments for: O, Cruel Fate
Talk to Greywing
If you are a HASA member, you must login to submit a comment.
We're sorry. Only HASA members may post comments. If you would like to speak with the author, please use the "Email Author" button in the Reader Toolbox. If you would like to join HASA, click here. Membership is free.
6 Comments
O, Cruel Fate
Greywing - 16 Nov 06 - 4:14 PM
Thank you all for reading and commenting!
oshun: I'm afraid your dear elf will have to suffer a tiny bit more.
erunyauve: Not very creative, the Elves of the Falas.
G.A: thanks for reading and recommending! You're a dear.
IVIaedhros: Cheers to you too! Glad it amused you for a while.
Go to O, Cruel Fate
O, Cruel Fate
Greywing - 06 Mar 07 - 7:03 AM
Thank you, Raksha and NiRi! I am genuinely pleased that it amused you, and that it didn't seem too Sueish (I hope).
Greywing
Go to O, Cruel Fate
O, Cruel Fate
Jay of Lasgalen - 23 Apr 07 - 5:12 AM
I've only just found this story, but I love it! 'Girl falls into Middle Earth' tales are usually dreary and formulaic, but this is simply hilarious. I loved Elrond on his high horse (quite literally!) and Ellie's bewilderment at waking up in the wrong body.
I've decided not to read anything personal into this sentence: 'Heavens, who would have thought the mere sight of a good-looking fellow would cause a group of civilized women to behave like a pack of starving hyenas?' Hmmm, who indeed?? 
Jay
Go to O, Cruel Fate
O, Cruel Fate
Greywing - 23 Apr 07 - 7:24 AM
Why thank you, Jay! I am overjoyed that you like it ;) This story is highly self-indulgent, so I'm glad it has some entertainment value!
And no, nothing personal in that line at all. Nope. 
Greywing
Go to O, Cruel Fate
O, Cruel Fate
Tyleet - 10 Jul 08 - 1:26 AM
Go to O, Cruel Fate
O, Cruel Fate
lilyoftheval5 - 02 Sep 08 - 5:49 AM
I liked the story - selectively.
I think the explanation of how she ended up in Arda was one of the most plausible ever contrived. I found Ellie's mishaps fun, but I wish there was much more.
Why selectively? Because all the happenings with Valar and in Mandos I simply skipped. I felt that they are ruining the story for me. *shrugs*
Thank you, I hope you'll copntinue to write.
Go to O, Cruel Fate
